
Graham BrookieµÄÊÖ»úÎËÎË×÷Ï죬°ÑËû´Ó³Á˯ÖоªÐÑ¡£ËûµÄÄÖÖÓÏìµÃÌ«ÔçÁË£¬ËûµÄ¹«Ô¢Ò»Æ¬ÆáºÚ¡£ËûÃþË÷×ÅÏÂÁË´²£¬ÊÖ»úÒ»±éÓÖÒ»±éµØÏì¸ö²»Í££¬Ëû°ÑÊÖ»úµ÷³ÉÁ˾²Òô¡£ÆÁÄ»ÉÏÊÇÎÞÇîÎÞ¾¡µÄÍþвÐÅÏ¢¡¢¹¥»÷ÐԵıíÇé°üºÍ³äÂúÒõıµÄÍÆÎÄ¡£´ó¶àÊýÈË»á¶ÔÉ罻ýÌåÉÏÆÌÌì¸ÇµØµÄ¿Ì±¡ÄÚÈݸе½Õ𾪣¬µ«BrookieÖ»ÊÇ·ÁË·°×ÑÛ¡£Ëû¶ÔÕâÖÖ¹¥»÷Ì«ÊìϤÁË£¬ÖªµÀ½ÓÏÂÀ´»á·¢Éúʲô¡£
ÔÚÒ»¸öÖ§³ÖÌØÀÊÆÕµÄYouTubeÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢ÍøÂçÄÚ²¿£¬¸ÃÍøÂ縲¸ÇÔ½ÄϺͲ¨Ë¹ÄáÑÇ
ÕâЩµãÁÁBrookieÊÖ»úµÄ֪ͨÊǶíÂÞ˹Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢Ô˶¯µÄÒ»²¿·Ö£¬ËûµÄ¹ÍÖ÷£¬´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»áµÄÊý×Ö·¨Ò½Ñо¿ÊµÑéÊÒ£¬Ìì³½×¢²áƽ̨ÕýÔÚÓëFacebookºÍÃÀ¹ú¹úÎñÔººÏ×÷¼à¿Ø¡£¶ÔÓÚÍâÐÐÈËÀ´Ëµ£¬ÕâЩÌû×Ó¿´ÆðÀ´ÊÇÕæʵµÄ£¬ÊÇͨ¹ýÕæʵµÄÕË»§·¢Ë͵ģ¬ÓÐÁîÈËÐÅ·þµÄÓû§Í·ÏñºÍ¼òÀú¡£È»¶ø£¬ÕâЩÕË»§±»Ò»Èº´ÓÊÂÓ°Ïì²Ù×÷¡¢·¢²¼“¼ÙÐÂÎÅ”¡¢ÔÚYoutTubeºÍÉç½»ÍøÕ¾ÉÏ´«²¥Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄ¾ÞħºÍ»úÆ÷ÈË¿ØÖÆ¡£
¸ú×ٺͽÒ¶Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢
2016ÄêÃÀ¹ú×Üͳ´óÑ¡Ö®ºó£¬Facebook¡¢TwitterºÍYouTubeµÈ¿Æ¼¼¹«Ë¾²»µÃ²»ÕýÊÓÕâÑùÒ»¸öÏÖʵ:²»·¨Ö®Í½ÎªÁËа¶ñµÄÄ¿µÄ²Ù×ÝÉ罻ýÌå¡£ÖøÃûµÄÊÇ£¬½£ÇÅ·ÖÎö¹«Ë¾(Cambridge Analytica)±»·¢ÏÖÔÚÑ¡¾ÙÆÚ¼äÀûÓÃFacebookÊý¾Ý£¬ÀûÓÃÕþÖÎÐû´«¶ÔÃÀ¹úÑ¡Ãñ½øÐÐ΢¹ÛÄ¿±êËø¶¨¡£¶àÄêÀ´£¬·´ÒßÃçÔ˶¯Ò»Ö±±»»úÆ÷È˺ÍÅç×Ó·Å´ó¡£Ëæ׏Ú×´²¡¶¾µÄ³ÖÐøÂûÑÓ£¬ÒõıÂÛÕß¿ªÊ¼É¢²¼Ò¥ÑÔ£¬ËµÕâÖÖ²¡¶¾¿ÉÒÔͨ¹ýÒûÓÃƯ°×¼Á»òÎüʳ¿É¿¨ÒòÀ´ÖÎÓú¡£
“É罻ýÌåƽ̨ÊÇÒ»³¡Ã¿Ì춼ÔÚÍøÉϽøÐеÄÐÅÏ¢Õ½µÄÕ½³¡£¬”Brookie˵¡£“»ù±¾ÊÂʵÊܵ½Á˹¥»÷¡£”ÆäÄ¿µÄÊÇץס²¢×ªÒÆÈËÃǶԷÖÁÑÐÔ»°ÌâµÄ×¢ÒâÁ¦¡£ÒòΪÀûÓÃÉ罻ýÌå²»¹ó£¬¶øÇÒÏà¶ÔÈÝÒ×£¬ËùÒÔ»µ½ÇÉ«ÊǶàÖÖ¶àÑùµÄ£¬²ßÂÔÒ²ÊÇÎÞµ³Åɵġ£
ÀýÈ磬¾¡¹Ü½£ÇÅ·ÖÎö¹«Ë¾(Cambridge Analytica)ÔÚ2016ÄêʹÓÃFacebookÊý¾Ý°ïÖú¹²ºÍµ³ºòÑ¡ÈËÌÆÄɵ·ÌØÀÊÆÕ(Donald Trump)£¬µ«´ÎÄêÃñÖ÷µ³²ßÂÔʦ¾Ý³ÆʹÓÃÁËÀàËƵÄÉ罻ýÌå²ßÂÔ£¬°ïÖúµÀ¸ñ·Çí˹(Doug Jones)ÔÚ°¢À°ÍÂíÖݵIJÎÒéÔºÌرðÑ¡¾ÙÖлñʤ(ÏÔÈ»Çí˹²¢²»ÖªÇé)¡£
ΪÁË´ò»÷Óк¦Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄ´«²¥£¬Ðí¶àÉ罻ýÌ幫˾ÒѾµ÷ÕûÁËËûÃǵÄÄÚÈÝÕþ²ß¡£Twitter×î½üÍƳöÁËһЩ¹¦ÄÜ£¬°ïÖúÓû§±ê¼ÇÓк¦ÄÚÈÝ£¬²¢ÎªÎóµ¼ÐÔÌû×ÓÌùÉϱêÇ©¡£YouTubeÔÝÍ£ÁË¿ÉÒÉÄÚÈݵĹã¸æ£¬ÆäÍƼöËã·¨Ò²²»ÔÙÌáÉýÒõıÂÛÄÚÈÝ¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á(Atlantic Council)Êý×Ö·¨Ò½Ñо¿ÊµÑéÊÒ(Digital Forensic Research Lab)¶Ô¶íÂÞ˹¿¹Òé»î¶¯µÄ·ÖÎö·¢ÏÖ£¬ÄªË¹¿Æµ»¯ÁË¿¹ÒéµÄ¹æÄ£¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á
×÷Ϊ¶Ô½£ÇÅ·ÖÎö¹«Ë¾(Cambridge Analytica)³óÎŵĻØÓ¦£¬2018Ä꣬FacebookÓëµÚÈý·½ÊÂʵºË²é»ú¹¹ºÏ×÷£¬ÆäÖаüÀ¨BrookieµÄ¹ÍÖ÷´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á(Atlantic Council)¡£´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á³ÉÁ¢ÓÚ1961Ä꣬×ܲ¿ÉèÔÚ»ªÊ¢¶ÙÌØÇø£¬ÊÇÒ»¸ö·ÇÓªÀûÐÔ¡¢ÎÞµ³ÅɵÄÖǿ⣬ÆäʹÃüÊǼÓÇ¿±±ÃÀºÍÅ·ÖÞÖ®¼äµÄÍâ½»ºÍ¾¼ÃºÏ×÷¡£´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»áÖ÷°ìÓÐÈ«ÇòÁìµ¼È˲μӵĻ£¬·¢±íÑо¿ÂÛÎÄ£¬²¢¹ÄÀø¾ÍÍøÂç³åÍ»µÈÓÐÕùÒéµÄÎÊÌâ´ï³ÉÕþ²ß¹²Ê¶¡£¸Ã×éÖ¯¶ÀÁ¢ÔË×÷£¬µ«½ÓÊܳ¬¹ý25¸öÕþ¸®µÄ×ÊÖú¡£ËüµÄ¾èÖúÕß°üÀ¨ÃÀ¹ú¹úÎñÔº¡¢·ÇÕþ¸®×éÖ¯ºÍ˽È˹«Ë¾¡£
Óë´ó¶àÊýÖÇ¿âÒ»Ñù£¬´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»áÒ²²¢·ÇûÓÐÕùÒ飬ż¶û»¹»áÊܵ½Ö¸Ô𣬳ÆһЩ¹ú¼ÒºÍ¹«Ë¾ÊÔͼͨ¹ý¾è¿îÀ´»ñÈ¡¶Ô¸Ã×éÖ¯µÄÓ°ÏìÁ¦¡£2014Ä꣬һ·Ý¹ØÓÚ¡¶¿ç´óÎ÷ÑóóÒ×ÓëͶ×Ê»ï°é¹Øϵ¡·(Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership£¬¼ò³Ættip)µÄ±¨¸æÔâµ½ÁËÅúÆÀ£¬ÒòΪ¸Ã¹«Ë¾µ±Ê±ÕýÔÚÓÎ˵ÃÀ¹ú¹ú»á½µµÍóÒ×¹ØË°¡£
FacebookÓëÓ¢¹úÊý¾Ý¹«Ë¾½£ÇÅ·ÖÎö(Cambridge Analytica)µÄ¹Øϵ´Ùʹ¸Ã¹«Ë¾Óë´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á(Atlantic Council)ºÏ×÷¡£
³öÓÚ¶ÔÉ罻ýÌåÈÕÒæÔö³¤µÄÓ°ÏìÁ¦µÄµ£ÓÇ£¬ÔøÔÚ°ÍÀ¿Ë·°Â°ÍÂí(Barack Obama)×ÜͳÊÖϵ£Èιú¼Ò°²È«Î¯Ô±»á(National Security Council)¹ËÎʵIJ¼Â³¼ª(Brookie)ÓÚ2016Äê´´½¨ÁËÊý×Ö·¨Ò½Ñо¿ÊµÑéÊÒ(Digital Forensic Research Lab)¡£ËüѸËٳɳ¤Îª´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á×î´óµÄ×éÖ¯Ö®Ò»¡£Ëû˵£¬ËüµÄʹÃüÊÇ´Ù½ø¿Í¹ÛÊÂʵ³ÉΪÕþ¸®µÄ»ù´¡¡£Ëû½âÊÍ˵:“ÎÒÃǵÄÍŶӳÉÔ±ÖÂÁ¦ÓÚ±£»¤ÃñÖ÷ÖƶȺ͹淶²»ÊÜÄÇЩÔÚÍøÉÏÆÆ»µËüÃǵÄÈ˵ÄÆÆ»µ£¬²¢ÔÚÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢·¢ÉúµÄʱ¼äºÍµØµãʶ±ð¡¢½Ò¶ºÍ½âÊÍÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢¡£”×Ô´Ó³ÉÁ¢ÒÔÀ´£¬DFRLÒѾ·¢±íÁ˳¬¹ý800¸ö°¸ÀýÑо¿£¬ÆäÖд󲿷ֿÉÒÔÔÚ¸Ã×éÖ¯µÄýÌ岩¿ÍÉÏÕÒµ½£¬±ÈÈç×î½üÂíÀ´Î÷ÑÇÑ¡¾ÙÖлúÆ÷È˵ÄʹÓ᣽ñÄêÔçЩʱºò£¬CNETÐÂÎźÍDFLRºÏ×÷µ÷²éÁËÒ»³¡Ô´ÓÚÔ½Äϵij¬µ³ÅÉÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢Ô˶¯¡£
Ò»¸öÉù³Æ¿É¿¨ÒòɱËÀ¹Ú×´²¡¶¾µÄÁ´½ÓÔÚFacebookÉϱ»ä¯ÀÀÁËÊýǧ´Î¡£
ÓÉCBS½Øͼ
ËäÈ»“¼ÙÐÂÎÅ”£¬µ«ÓÉÓÚDFRLÍŶӵÄÓïÑÔºÜÖØÒª£¬´íÎóÐÅÏ¢ºÍÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢³£³£¿ÉÒÔ»¥»»Ê¹Óá£×Ô2016Äê´óÑ¡ÒÔÀ´£¬“¼ÙÐÂÎŔһ´Ê¼¸ºõÊDz»¿É±ÜÃâµÄ£¬µ«¸ÃÍŶӱÜÃâʹÓÃÕâ¸ö´Ê£¬ÒòΪËü±»“È«Çò¸÷µØµÄÍþȨÖ÷ÒåÕßÓÃÀ´¶ôÖÆÒìÒ飬ÈÃÕæÕýµÄ¼ÇÕß´¦ÓÚΣÏÕÖ®ÖУ¬”Brookie˵¡£
Òò´Ë£¬DFRLÔÚÆäÑо¿ÖÐÓÅÏÈ¿¼ÂÇ͸Ã÷¶È£¬²¢¾³£ÊÔͼÔÚÆ䱨¸æÖÐʹÓÓ¿ª·Å”Êý¾Ý¡£¹«¿ªÊý¾ÝÊǶԹ«ÖÚ¿ª·ÅµÄÐÅÏ¢——ÀýÈ磬¹È¸è½Ö¾°»ò¹«¿ª·¢²¼µÄ¾üÊÂÉèʩͼƬ——Õâ¿ÉÄÜΪÑо¿·ÖÎöʦÌṩÓÐÓõÄÏßË÷¡£
“»µÑÝÔ±¼¸ºõ×ÜÊDz»Í¸Ã÷µÄ¡£ÎÒÃÇÊÇÏà·´µÄ¡£ÎÒÃǵŤ×÷Ó¦¸Ã½ÓÊÜ×Ðϸ¼ì²é¡£¿ªÔ´Ñо¿µÄÈ«²¿ÒâÒå¾ÍÔÚÓÚ£¬Ê¹ÎÒÃǵŤ×÷£¬Ìì³½×¢²áƽ̨°üÀ¨ÎÒÃǵÄÀ´Ô´¡¢·½·¨ºÍ½áÂÛ£¬¹«¿ªÍ¸Ã÷£¬”Brookie˵¡£
DFRL×îÓÐÃûµÄ¿ÉÄÜÊÇËü2015ÄêµÄ±¨¸æ¡¶Òþ²ØÔÚÑÛƤµ×ÏÂ:ÆÕ¾©ÔÚÎÚ¿ËÀ¼µÄÕ½Õù¡·(in Plain Sight: Putin’s War in Ukraine)£¬¸Ã±¨¸æʹÓù«¿ªÊý¾Ý£¬°üÀ¨¶íÂÞ˹¾ü¶ÓÅÄÉã²¢·¢²¼ÔÚÉ罻ýÌåÉϵÄ×ÔÅÄÕÕ£¬À´Ö¤Ã÷¶íÂÞ˹ռÁìÁËÎÚ¿ËÀ¼¶«²¿£¬¶íÂÞ˹×Üͳ¸¥À»ùÃ׶û·ÆÕ¾©(Vladimir Putin)µ±Ê±·ñÈÏÁËÕâÒ»Ö¸¿Ø¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á(Atlantic Council)µÄÊý×ÖÈ¡Ö¤Ñо¿ÊµÑéÊÒ(Digital Forensic Research Lab)ÒѾÔÚ´ó¶àÊýÖ÷ÒªÉ罻ýÌåƽ̨ÉÏ·¢ÏÖÁËÊýǧÆðÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á
BrookieµÄÑо¿ÍŶӽ«Í¸Ã÷µÄ¿ª·ÅÊý¾ÝÑо¿¼¼ÊõÓ¦ÓÃÓÚËûÃÇ×Ô¼ºµÄרÓÐÐÅÏ¢¡£2016Ä꣬¸ÃС×é·¢²¼ÁËÒ»·ÝÃûΪ¡¶´òÆÆ°¢ÀÕÆÄ¡·(Breaking Aleppo)µÄ±¨¸æ£¬¼Ç¼ÁË°¢ÈøµÂÕþȨ¶ÔÕâ×ùÐðÀûÑdzÇÊз¢¶¯¹¥»÷ÆÚ¼äµÄÈËȨÇÖ·¸£¬°üÀ¨Õ½Õù×ï¡£
“Õâ×î³õ¿ªÔ´Ñо¿¼¯ÖÐÔÚ·â±ÕµÄÐÅÏ¢»·¾³,ÎÒÃDz»µÃ²»°Ñ×÷Æ··ÅÔÚÒ»ÆðµÄÕûÌåÆÀ¹ÀºÍ¿ªÔ´ÉçÇøÈÔÈ»ÊÇ˼¿¼Ê¹ÓÃÔÚÏß²ÄÁϵÄÖ¤¾Ý±ê×¼µ÷²éÕ½Õù×ï,“ÕûÌì½âÊ͵À¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»áµÄGraham Brookie
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á
DFRLÍŶÓʹÓÿªÔ´ºÍÉÌÒµ¼¼Êõ²úÆ·£¬Èç¹È¸èÎĵµ£¬´ÓÉç½»ÍøÂçÖÐÌáÈ¡¹«¿ªÊý¾Ý£¬ÒÔʶ±ðºÍ±ê¼Ç²»ÕæʵµÄ»¥ÁªÍøÄÚÈÝ£¬½«Æä¹éÀàΪ“´íÎóÐÅÏ¢”»ò“Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢”¡£
Brookie½âÊÍ˵£¬Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢ÊÇûÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄ´«²¥:“Ëü¸ü±»¶¯£¬¸üÆձ锣¬±ÈÈçÒ»¸öЦ»°»òÒ¥ÑÔ¡£Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢ÊÇΪÁË´ïµ½ÕþÖΡ¢Éç»á»ò¾¼ÃÄ¿µÄ¶ø´«²¥µÄÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢¡£
DFRLÍŶӵķÖÎöʦ×ÐϸµØÔÚµç×Ó±í¸ñÖмǼÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄģʽºÍʵÀý£¬È»ºó½«ÕâЩÊý¾ÝÌṩ¸øFacebookµÈ¹«Ë¾£¬ÕâЩ¹«Ë¾½«¹«¿ªÊý¾ÝÓ빫˾µÄ˽ÈËÈÕÖ¾½áºÏÆðÀ´£¬²¢Í¨¹ýɾ³ýÐé¼ÙµÄ¸öÈË×ÊÁÏ¡¢Ò³ÃæºÍ×éÀ´²ÉÈ¡Ðж¯¡£
µ±ÕâЩÐͬµÄÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢²»±»×¢ÒâºÍ¼ì²éʱ£¬ËüÃǾͻáÅ·¢Õ¹¡£ÎªÁË°ïÖú¹«ÖÚ¸üºÃµØÀí½âÕâЩ»î¶¯µÄÆÕ±éÐÔ£¬DFRLÔÚGitHubÉÏ·¢²¼ÁËÊý°Ù¸öÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄÀý×Ó£¬²¢Óë¹È¸èµÄJigsawÒ»Æð´´½¨ÁËÒ»¸öÃûΪ“Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢¶þ·Ö·¨”µÄÊý¾Ý¿ÉÊÓ»¯¹¤¾ß¡£½»»¥Ê½µØͼÔÊÐíÓû§ÉîÈë²é¿´Ìض¨µÄÄ¿±êºÍƽ̨£¬ÒÔ¼°ÏÂÔØÔ´²ÄÁϵĵç×Ó±í¸ñ¡£
¾ÝÊý×Ö·¨Ò½Ñо¿ÊµÑéÊÒµÄÑо¿ÈËÔ±³Æ£¬²£ÀûάÑǵÄÕþÖζ¯ÂÒÊÇÓɲ»ÕæʵµÄ»î¶¯¡¢·ñÈÏ·¢ÉúÕþÖÎÕþ±äµÄ»úÆ÷È˺ÍÄ£ÒòÒý·¢µÄ¡£
´óÎ÷ÑóÀíÊ»á
ÊÀ½ç¾¼ÃÂÛ̳(World Economic Forum)ºÍµÂ¹úÂíЪ¶û»ù½ð»á(German Marshall Fund)±£ÕÏÃñÖ÷ÁªÃË(Alliance for secure Democracy)µÈÀàËÆÖÇ¿âµÄר¼ÒÈÏΪ£¬×Ü»áÓлµÈËÀûÓÃÉç½»ÍøÂç´«²¥Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢¡£µ«ÈËÃÇÒ»ÖÂÈÏΪ£¬¶ôÖÆÆäÓ°ÏìµÄ×î¼Ñ·½Ê½ÊÇͨ¹ý½ÌÓýºÍ¹«ÖÚÒâʶ¡£BrookieÏàÐÅ£¬Í¨¹ýÓëFacebookºÍJigsawµÈ¹«Ë¾µÄºÏ×÷£¬DFRLÒѾÄܹ»ÒÔÒ»ÖֿɳÖÐøµÄ·½Ê½À´½â¾öÕâ¸öÎÊÌâ¡£
“Ðé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢ÊÇÒ»¸ö¼¯ÌåÌôÕ½£¬ËüÐèÒª°üÀ¨Õþ¸®¡¢Ã½Ìå¡¢É罻ýÌåƽ̨——×îÖØÒªµÄÊÇ——ÎÒÃÇÿһ¸öÈËÔÚÄڵļ¯ÌåÓ¦¶Ô£¬”Brookie˵¡£Ê¶±ð¡¢½Ò¶ºÍ½âÊÍÐé¼ÙÐÅÏ¢µÄ¹¤×÷ÊÇÐ×÷µÄ£¬¶øÇÒ³£³£Êǵü´úµÄ¡£ÎÒÃǼáÐÅ£¬×öÕâÏ×÷µÄÈËÔ½¶àÔ½ºÃ¡£Õâ¾ÍÊÇΪʲôÎÒÃÇÕýÓëÎÒÃǵÄÍŶӺÏ×÷£¬Èùú¼ÊÉç»á(ÎÒÃǵĵ÷²éÈËÔ±)ÖÂÁ¦ÓÚΪÊÂʵ¶øÕ½¡£”